top of page

GRANNY FAY'S PIE & SANDWICH SHOP

It's delicious and I love it!

92B6D4A0-EF5D-4E70-8364-38F055DED91B.jpeg
Granny Fay's Menu: Welcome
31B1B30D-951F-4758-8712-BFAFFD1BD6A0.jpeg

OPENING HOURS

Come Visit!

Closed for the Season!
Watch for our 2023 Hours!
We do take special pie orders for Thanksgiving, Christmas and Valentines in our off season! So watch for our special pie ordering and pickup times!

Granny Fay's Menu: Opening Hours

MENU

BACON RANCH CLUB

$ 9.25

shaved turkey, bacon, spinach, onions, tomato, muenster cheese,
& homemade ranch dressing
+ chips

CHEERY CHERRY TURKEY +
GOAT CHEESE

Shaved turkey, spinach, onion, goat cheese, & special cherry sauce
+ chips

$ 8.50

SWEET HAMMY SAMMY

Shaved ham, muenster cheese, tomato, spinach, & homemade poppyseed dressing
+ chips

$ 7.95

GRILLED CHEESE

$ 6.50 / 4.25

Muenster cheese, co-jack, & cheddar cheese on our buttery homemade artisan bread (can add any sauce)
+ chips

AVOCADO TOAST

$ 6.95

Avocado spread onto a slice of our toasted homemade artisan bread topped with tomatoes, goat cheese crumble, & bacon crumble

GOAT CHEESE +
JAM TOAST

Goat cheese spread onto a slice of our homemade artisan bread topped with your choice of strawberry or cherry jam

$ 4.95

WHIPPED GOAT CHEESE + HONEY

Our homemade artisan bread served with a side of whipped goat cheese + honey

$ 7.95

MIXED GREENS + FRUIT

Spring salad mix with fresh fruit (strawberries & blueberries or seasonal fruit), onions, & goat cheese
with homemade poppy seed dressing served with sweet corn bread

$ 8.25

MIXED GREENS WITH VEGGIES

Spring salad mix with choice of fresh veggies in season with homemade ranch dressing served with sweet corn bread

$ 8.25

TOMATO SOUP

Cup of tomato soup topped with sour cream, parmesan cheese and croutons

$ 5.95 / 4.75

1/2 SANDWICH 1/2 SALAD OR SOUP

Choice of sandwich and choice of salad 
(1/2 grilled cheese and 1/2 soup or salad / 7.95)

$ 9.25

Granny Fay's Menu: List
bottom of page